Deep Thinking Might Be What We Need Right Now
Updated: Nov 12
“If you would be a writer, first be a reader. Only through the assimilation of ideas, thoughts, and philosophies can one begin to focus his own ideas, thoughts, and philosophies.”
-Allan W. Ecker
I love words, big ones, small ones, and funny ones, like gobbledygook or discombobulated. Today, I had the opening lines of, Jabberwocky, by Lewis Carroll, floating through my head, like a 33” vinyl record stuck in a scratch.
’Twas brillig, and the slithy toves
Did gyre and gimble in the wabe:
All mimsy were the borogoves,
And the mome raths outgrabe.
Oh, what delicious nonsense full of meaning and misty terror, that unleashes the imagination and tickles the funny bone. I always included Jabberwocky in my poetry unit for tenth graders when I taught high school English. That was back some forty-plus years ago. I wonder if anyone teaches that poem now. I hope so.
Words deliver knowledge. They make us think, and they make us stretch if we let them, if we invest in them. Reading words unlocks ideas, the substance of our intellect.
For some learners it is curiosity about math, chemistry, or astronomy that entices them to seek deep knowledge. For me it was information on what it means to be human. I wanted to know how humans become human, particularly through learning and interacting with other each other.
I also wanted to know where knowledge came from, how it was created or discovered, how I could get access to it, and how to evaluate its value and usefulness. I had spent time reading secondary sources, but I needed to see those ideas in their original output.
So, at fifty-some years of age, I signed up to get a PhD in human development. Why not? I loved learning, especially when it involved words, and the stories were about people. How hard could it be?
Reading my first research article was an assault on my brain’s wiring. To get through its dense language and complicated ideas, I decided to read it out loud. Seeing and hearing the words made my mind bend to the task, a little bit.
I had very little background knowledge in what I was studying, so the ideas were difficult to grasp, and the science behind generating this kind of knowledge was new to me, but over the years of reading research and eventually doing my own, it got easier, and then I couldn’t get enough of it.
Not only did I do research, but I learned how to write articles and get my own research published. Wrapping my mind around complicated information and weaving my own studies into others’ knowledge gave me a high. I had crossed over to the place where thinking hard was fun.
It was a gift I never dreamed I would welcome. That experience, however, is in jeopardy. Artificial intelligence (AI) has the wherewithal to steal real learning away from us.
With AI, the energy is focused on what the receiver gets, not what the creator did. I can receive a charming text from someone who knows me well, but with little effort or engagement on their part. AI makes it easy and fast.
But I question what the sender is getting from the process of acknowledging me when AI is involved. In the act of writing to someone, we ponder that person and the meaning of the relationship. Something gets lost when AI does our writing. Less involvement equals less connection between the sender and the receiver.
David Brooks of the New York Times published an opinion on the effects of using AI or even a search engine to generate our ideas and write them down. His comments reflect a study that makes it clear that using AI or search engines to help us construct prose leaves us knowing less than if we had relied exclusively on our own gray matter.
The point is that writing requires that one has ideas and understands them well enough to translate them into prose. Writing is an expression of what a person knows. If robots do our writing, we don’t learn very much.
Several years ago, before the proliferation of AI, while teaching writing at a community college, I encountered students who didn’t understand that plagiarism was considered fraud, that it was stealing someone’s words and ideas and claiming them as one’s own.
But what was also lost was the thinking that is required to learn. Thinking can be hard, but as with working out and pushing our physical muscles to get stronger, thinking that is hard stretches our abilities to know more.
One of the activities that helps us expand our ability to think deeply is reading, especially writing that deals with complexities and nuance. Most of us are averse to this kind of reading. It requires time, effort, and perseverance.
That was the kind of reading that I learned to do in my PhD studies. In the beginning it was slow going and hard, but it got easier the longer and harder I worked at it. And in the end the payoff was that I developed the neural pathways to also write with precision and clarity about my own and others’ intellectual work.
Not everyone needs a PhD to achieve that kind of skill, but I did because I couldn’t do it on my own. I required guidance and coaching to see me through the process. The transformational experience of acquiring that skill would never have happened if I had used AI or search engines. I would have missed the satisfaction of getting to the other side of the challenge.
Having spent my whole life in the world of teaching and learning, I am saddened by the ways that AI will rob us of real learning and deep thinking. It will be a personal loss, but it will also have wide social implications for how we assess problems and solve them. We will not be up to managing the complexities of our world. Fast and easy is coming at a price.
So, what can any one of us do?
Play with AI when you want to see how it works but rely more on your own mind for substance. As I write this piece, the icon for AI pops in and out of the margin. Choose to avoid clicking on the AI icon when you are doing serious work.
Read books printed on paper. Horizontal eye movements are better for us than the vertical scrolling we do on our screens.
Get out of the screens that trap us in social media and train our brains to think in short quips.
Challenge yourself every once in a while to read something that is deep and nuanced. Push yourself to grasp and retain its meaning.
Find or create a community of those who love to learn. Read together. Write to each other. Talk to each other. Connect ideas. Take classes together. Dabble in poetry.
Neil Postman was prescient when it came to knowing that screen media would not serve us well in the long run. He understood that screens would weaken our ability to think deeply. In my own writing I draw from his book on Amusing Ourselves to Death:
Postman argues that prior to television, our ideas about education, knowledge, truth, and information—all realms of the intellect—were explained, and expanded upon by thinking that was presented to us through the printed word.
Developing ideas, knowledge, and truth involved writing and thinking—and maybe consulting other writers and thinkers in the process. Writing down one’s ideas took time then and it takes time now. It is not lightning fast.
It is slow and deliberate. Stating a point or a proposition, and then backing it up with evidence requires thinking, writing, rethinking, and rewriting.
Reducing such thinking into sound bites does a disservice to intellectual honesty, and compromises the validity of ideas, and thus, knowledge.
Stuck in Our Screens, p. 5
As we all struggle through a time when intellectual growth and knowledge are in decline, may we remember the value of deep reading and thinking, and may we keep it alive.





Beautifully explained and I do appreciate words and thoughts I’m able to write in my journal whenever I feeel like it! As for reading I do struggle reading page 1 to the end because my brain says jump to what feeds you in which chapter can dictate tag lines!